Watch the clip
Script + sources
“But 16 is legal!”
If you’ve been following the news about Russell Brand, David Walliams and allegations of sexual misconduct in the entertainment industry, you’ve probably seen this argument coming up.
When allegations involve much older men and teenage girls, some people point to the legal age of consent as though being 16 automatically means any sexual activity was consensual, and that the person making the allegation simply changed their mind afterwards.
But that’s not how consent works. Being old enough to legally consent doesn’t mean someone actually consented. And there’s another question worth asking.
In the UK, the age of consent is 16. That means that, in most circumstances, a 30-year-old can legally have consensual sex with a 16-year-old.
But should that be legal?
That’s the question being raised by a campaign called Close the Consent Gap, which is calling for a staggered age of consent.
Under its proposal, 16- and 17-year-olds would still be able to have consensual sexual relationships with people close to their own age, but sex with someone more than three years older would become a criminal offence.
One way of making this possible would be through what’s commonly known as a Romeo and Juliet clause.
These are close-in-age exceptions found in countries like Italy, France and Canada, allowing young people to have consensual sex with someone around their own age, even when they’re below the general age of consent.
For example, imagine the UK raised the general age of consent to 18 but introduced a close-in-age exception.
A 16-year-old having sex with a 17-year-old? Legal.
A 16-year-old having sex with a 30-year-old? Illegal.
Of course, this raises other questions. Where should we draw the age boundary? Could changing the law have unintended consequences for young people? And would it actually help prevent grooming and sexual exploitation?
So, what do you think? Should the law treat a sexual relationship between two teenagers in the same way as one between a teenager and someone twice their age?
Main image: a composite of a photo by Gage Skidmore and one by Sriya Sarkar